Annuity Atlas
Reviews

Expert review · 2025

North American review

Strong carrier offering diverse fixed indexed annuities with solid A+ financial ratings.

Our rating

4.0
Avg ★ / 5
Products reviewed26
A.M. BestA+
S&PA
Get my free review
Founded
1926
Headquarters
Chicago, IL
Total assets
$120+ Billion
A.M. Best
A+
01

26 North American annuities reviewed

Sorted by star rating. Click any product for the full peer-group review.

ProductTypeSurrenderRatingIncome riderBonus
Income Pay Pro
Pre-retirees age 50-70 using long-term dollars who want to lock in a future income floor, plan to defer activation for several years, and value a built-in rider rather than an optional one
Income10yr 4.3Yes
1.15% of GLWB value annually (current); maximum 2.00% fee
Review →
Max Elite Guarantee 5-Year
Conservative savers who want a locked 5-year guaranteed rate with a credible carrier and a clean, no-rider structure
MYGA5yrA+Review →
Max Elite Guarantee 7-Year
Conservative savers who want a fully locked rate for seven years with no crediting complexity and no rider overhead
MYGA7yrA+Review →
NAC Guarantee Plus 5-Year
Savers who want a guaranteed fixed rate for five years, a clean structure with no rider complexity, and the backing of an A+ rated carrier
MYGA5yrA+Review →
NAC Guaranteed Allocation 5
Accumulation-focused buyers who want index-linked growth potential and value knowing their caps and participation rates won't be reset during the surrender period
FIA5yr 4.2Review →
Charter Plus 10
Buyers who want a meaningful upfront premium bonus, principal protection, and a broad crediting menu inside a 10-year contract
FIA10yr 4.27% ($20,000-$74,999) or 10% ($75,000+) base bonus; optional enhanced bonus rider adds 9% for 0.95% annual chargeReview →
Secure Horizon Plus
Buyers who want a large upfront premium boost, built-in lifetime income, and chronic illness protection in a single contract
FIA10yr 4.2Yes
1.20% - 1.45% annually fee
22% (includes 2% premium bonus special, subject to modification or discontinuation)Review →
Max Elite Guarantee 3-Year
Savers who want a short, guaranteed-rate commitment from a top-rated carrier without rider complexity
MYGA3yrA+Review →
NAC BenefitSolutions 10
Pre-retirees who want guaranteed lifetime income built directly into the contract and want the nursing-home multiplier without paying a separate rider fee
Income10yr 4.1Yes
1.20% annually fee
Review →
NAC Guarantee Plus 7-Year
Savers who want a locked rate from an A+ carrier for seven years with clean free-withdrawal terms and no rider complexity
MYGA7yrA+Review →
NAC Guaranteed Allocation 10
Buyers who want locked crediting terms for the full surrender period and are comfortable choosing from a set of blended multi-index allocation models
FIA10yr 4.1Review →
Max Elite Accumulation 5
Buyers who want a shorter FIA commitment, principal protection, and a fixed account fallback without paying for an income rider they do not need
FIA5yr 4.0Review →
Max Elite Accumulation 7
Buyers who want principal protection and index-linked growth potential over a 7-year horizon, with the option to lock in a declared floor for additional downside cushion
FIA7yr 4.0Review →
NAC Control X
Pre-retirees who want long-term principal protection and the option to build guaranteed income through a participating rollup without locking into rider costs at issue
FIA10yr 4.010% one-time bonus applied to initial deferred income baseReview →
NAC Guaranteed Allocation 7
Accumulation-focused buyers who want index-linked growth potential with rate certainty locked in for the full surrender period and no annual product fee
FIA7yr 4.0Review →
NAC VersaChoice 10
Pre-retirees who want a 10-year FIA with a broad index menu, meaningful free-withdrawal flexibility, and the option to add income coverage later
FIA10yr 4.0Review →
Secure Horizon Choice 7
Buyers who want principal protection with a broad index menu and the option to add income and chronic illness coverage later without committing to a rider fee upfront
FIA7yr 4.0Review →
NAC Guarantee Plus 3-Year
Conservative savers who want a short, locked-rate commitment with a strong carrier behind it and no complexity to manage
MYGA3yrA+Review →
Secure Horizon Accelerator
Buyers who want a meaningful upfront premium bonus on long-term accumulation dollars and do not need a guaranteed income rider
FIA10yr 3.916-17% depending on state (includes 4% premium bonus special)Review →
Secure Horizon Choice 5
Buyers who want a shorter FIA commitment with a broad index menu and the option to add a low-cost income rider later without paying for it upfront
FIA5yr 3.9Review →
PrimePath Pro 12
Buyers in their late 50s through early 70s who want a long deferral window, a built-in lifetime income rider with no separate fee, and a chronic-illness payment doubler
Income12yr 3.9Yes5% at year 5 and 5% at year 10 if conditions met (no withdrawals or LPAs)Review →
Max Elite Accumulation 10
Long-horizon retirement savers who want index-linked growth potential with a guaranteed floor option and no desire for a built-in income rider
FIA10yr 3.8Review →
Secure Horizon
Conservative accumulators who want a diverse crediting menu and principal protection over a 10-year window without paying for income features they don't need
FIA10yr 3.8Review →
Performance Choice 8
Accumulation-focused buyers who want index variety, principal protection, and no income rider cost, and who are comfortable committing to an 8-year surrender window
FIA8yr 3.8Review →
Charter Plus 14
Buyers with a long time horizon who want a meaningful upfront premium bonus and can genuinely commit to a 14-year lockup
FIA14yr 3.713% ($20,000-$74,999) or 17% ($75,000+) on premiums in first 3 yearsReview →
PrimePath Pro 10
Buyers in their 50s or 60s who want a built-in lifetime income rider with no separate fee, plan to defer income for ten years or more, and value an A+ rated carrier over a chase for the highest possible roll-up
Income10yr 3.7YesReview →
02

About North American

North American Company for Life and Health Insurance is a subsidiary of Sammons Financial Group. Known for a deep portfolio of fixed indexed annuities spanning accumulation, income, and principal-protection strategies, North American offers broad index crediting menus and meaningful rider options. The carrier's A+ A.M. Best rating reflects strong financial stability, making it a credible choice for long-duration contracts.

03

How we scored them

Income Options85/100
Financial Strength94/100
Fees & Costs80/100
Flexibility78/100
Customer Service83/100
04

The tradeoffs

What works
  • Excellent A+ A.M. Best financial strength rating
  • Deep FIA product portfolio with multiple tenure bands (3-14 years)
  • Generous premium bonuses on accumulation products (up to 10%)
  • Built-in income riders with compounded roll-ups on income products (8% annually)
  • Nursing home waivers and care accelerators built into many products
What to watch
  • Long surrender periods (10-14 years on flagship accumulation products)
  • Market Value Adjustments add interest-rate risk on early exits
  • Income rider fees (1.15-1.20%) apply whether or not income is activated
  • Not available in New York; limited availability in some states
  • Proprietary index strategies carry less transparent track records than benchmarks
05

What you could receive

Estimated guaranteed lifetime income based on a single premium payment. Actual rates may vary.

InvestmentAgeMonthlyAnnualGuarantee
$100,00060$515$6,180Lifetime
$250,00065$1,425$17,100Lifetime
$500,00065$2,850$34,200Lifetime
$1,000,00070$6,450$77,400Lifetime
06

Fee schedule

Fee typeAmountDescription
Annual Contract Fee$0No annual maintenance fee on base contracts
Income Rider Fee1.15-1.20%Annual fee on income rider value; applies whether or not income is activated
Surrender ChargeVaries by productDeclining schedule over 5-14 year periods; MVA applies during surrender window
07

Early withdrawal penalties

Charges apply to amounts above the annual free withdrawal (typically 10%).

Yr 1Yr 2Yr 3Yr 4Yr 5Yr 6Yr 7Yr 8Yr 9Yr 10
10%9%8%7%6%5%4%3%2%1%
08

Best fit for these buyers

Accumulators seeking long-term growth with principal protection and broad index options
Income-focused retirees valuing built-in lifetime income guarantees with care protections
Buyers comfortable with 5-10+ year commitments in exchange for strong carrier backing
Ages 50-75 planning retirement income or long-horizon accumulation
09

Frequently asked questions

Is North American a good annuity company?
North American earns an average rating of 4.0/5 across the 26 products we've reviewed, with an AM Best rating of A+ and S&P rating of A. Their financial strength is rated "Excellent" with $120+ Billion in total assets. North American is particularly strong in financial strength.
How much income can I get from a North American annuity?
Income depends on your investment amount and age. For example, a $500,000 investment at age 65 could generate approximately $34,200 per year in guaranteed lifetime income. A $250,000 investment at the same age could generate about $17,100 per year.
What are the fees for North American annuities?
North American charges Annual Contract Fee: $0, Income Rider Fee: 1.15-1.20%, Surrender Charge: Varies by product. Notably, there is no annual contract fee on the base contract, which is a competitive advantage.
What is the surrender period for North American annuities?
North American annuities typically have a 10-year surrender period. Charges start at 10% in year one and decline to 1% in the final year. Most products allow 10% annual free withdrawals without penalty.

See your North American income projection

  • Personalized estimate
  • Based on age, premium & goals
  • No pressure, no pitch.
Compare North American