Annuity Atlas
Reviews

Expert review · 2025

Nationwide review

Diversified Fortune 100 insurer offering a full spectrum of annuity products.

Our rating

3.9
Avg ★ / 5
Products reviewed55
A.M. BestA+
S&PA+
Get my free review
Founded
1926
Headquarters
Columbus, OH
Total assets
$280+ Billion
A.M. Best
A+
01

55 Nationwide annuities reviewed

Sorted by star rating. Click any product for the full peer-group review.

ProductTypeSurrenderRatingIncome riderBonus
Nationwide Monument Advisor
Larger-account investors working with fee-based advisors who want tax-deferred growth, full liquidity, and the broadest possible investment menu at a fraction of traditional VA costs
Variable0yr 4.5Review →
Nationwide INCOME Promise Select
Buyers who want immediate guaranteed income with more payout flexibility and liquidity access than most SPIAs offer
Income0yr 4.4Review →
Nationwide New Heights Select 10
Buyers who want the most competitive crediting terms in the standard New Heights Select line with full rider flexibility and broad state availability
FIA10yr 4.3Yes
0.95% (income) or 0.50% (EDB) fee
3% (EDB with Bonus rider)Review →
Nationwide Stable Income
Buyers who want guaranteed lifetime income from a fixed annuity without the complexity of an indexed product, backed by a Fortune 100 carrier
Income7yr 4.3Yes
0.95% (built-in) fee
Review →
Nationwide New Heights Select 8
Buyers who want a low-minimum, principal-protected FIA with a 7-index BAS crediting menu and the flexibility to add either an income or enhanced death benefit rider
FIA8yr 4.2Yes
0.95% (income) or 0.50% (EDB) fee
Review →
Nationwide New Heights Select 9
Buyers who want 3-year strategy terms for potentially higher growth, a 7-index BAS crediting menu, and optional income or death benefit riders
FIA9yr 4.2Yes
0.95% (income) or 0.50% (EDB) fee
4% (EDB with Bonus rider)Review →
Nationwide L.inc+ Core Advisory
Fee-based advisor clients who want the cost efficiency of an advisory VA with the added flexibility of optional living benefit riders for income planning
Variable0yr 4.2Yes
Varies by rider elected fee
Review →
Nationwide Peak 10
Buyers who want accumulation-first with a built-in income option they can activate later, without paying an extra rider fee
FIA10yr 4.1Yes
No fee (built-in) fee
Review →
Nationwide New Heights Select 12
Younger buyers with a very long time horizon who want the most aggressive crediting features including 3-year strategy terms and the highest EDB bonus
FIA12yr 4.1Yes
0.95% (income) or 0.55% (EDB) fee
5% (EDB with Bonus rider)Review →
Advisory Retirement Income Annuity
Investors working with a fee-only advisor who want market-based growth in a tax-deferred wrapper, a very low base contract cost, and the option to bolt on lifetime income later
Variable0yr 4.1Yes
Core Advisory (Single): 1.30% (max 1.50%); Core Advisory (Joint): 1.60% (max 1.90%); Accelerated Advisory (Single): 1.30% (max 1.50%); Accelerated Advisory (Joint): 1.60% (max 1.90%); Pro 4 (Single): 0.45% (max 0.55%); Pro 4 (Joint): 0.60% (max 0.70%) fee
Review →
Defender Annuity
Buyers who want more index upside than a fixed indexed annuity can offer and are willing to absorb a slice of market loss in exchange for a higher ceiling
FIA6yr 4.1Review →
Defined Protection Annuity 2.0
Buyers who want index-linked growth but are uncomfortable with the partial downside exposure that most RILAs require
FIA6yr 4.1Review →
Secure Growth 5-Year
Savers with $100,000 or more who want a clean 5-year locked rate, immediate free-withdrawal access, and an A+ carrier behind the guarantee
MYGA5yrA+Review →
Secure Growth 5-Year with MVA
Savers who want a guaranteed 5-year rate, can commit $100,000 or more for the higher tier, and are comfortable with a market value adjustment feature
MYGA5yrA+Review →
Secure Growth 5-Year with ROP
Conservative savers who want a locked 5-year rate with a hard floor against principal loss and no market value adjustment risk
MYGA5yrA+Review →
Secure Growth 7-Year
Conservative savers who want a guaranteed fixed rate locked for seven years, full principal protection, and no interest-rate risk on money they do not plan to touch
MYGA7yrA+Review →
Secure Growth 7-Year with MVA
Retirement savers who want a locked 7-year guaranteed rate from a highly rated carrier with no rider complexity
MYGA7yrA+Review →
Secure Growth 7-Year with ROP
Conservative savers who want a guaranteed 7-year locked rate from a highly rated carrier and want the peace of mind that they can always get at least their premium back
MYGA7yrA+Review →
Nationwide Secure Growth
Buyers who want a guaranteed fixed rate from a top-rated carrier with the flexibility to choose from multiple guarantee periods in a single product
MYGA7yrA+Review →
Personal Income Annuity
Buyers working with a Fidelity advisor who want a built-in lifetime income guarantee on a variable annuity with a short 5-year surrender window
Income5yr 4.0Yes
1.30% annually, charged on Benefit Base fee
Review →
Secure Growth 3-Year
Conservative savers who want a short guaranteed-rate period, a trusted carrier name, and immediate access to a free-withdrawal amount from day one
MYGA3yrA+Review →
CareMatters
Retirees aged 40–80 who want to fund potential long-term care costs using nonqualified savings without removing money from their estate until needed
MYGA10yrA+Review →
Platinum Edge 6-Year
Retirement savers who want a locked six-year rate from a highly rated carrier, a low entry minimum, and a clean transition process at the end of the guarantee period
MYGA6yrA+Review →
Platinum Edge 7-Year
Conservative savers who want a locked seven-year rate from a strong carrier and can commit funds they won't need liquid access to beyond the free-withdrawal amount
MYGA7yrA+Review →
Nationwide Peak 5
Buyers who want a shorter-duration FIA with a broader index menu than Summit, backed by a Fortune 100 carrier
FIA5yr 3.9Review →
Nationwide Destination Navigator 2.0
Buyers who want market-linked accumulation with the flexibility to add guaranteed income riders later, and who value purchase payment credits on larger deposits
Variable7yr 3.9Yes
Varies by rider elected fee
0.50–1.00%Review →
Secure Growth 3-Year with MVA
Conservative savers who want a short, guaranteed-rate commitment with a well-rated carrier and can accept a market value adjustment on early withdrawals
MYGA3yrA+Review →
Secure Growth 4-Year
Conservative savers who want a short, locked guaranteed rate with a nationally recognized carrier and a clean exit after four years
MYGA4yrA+Review →
Secure Growth 4-Year with MVA
Conservative savers who want a short, clean rate lock with a name-brand carrier and are comfortable with the MVA structure
MYGA4yrA+Review →
Peak 5 Series A
Conservative accumulators who want a short FIA commitment, two index choices, and no rider complexity
FIA5yr 3.9Review →
Platinum Edge 8-Year
Retirement savers with a true 8-year horizon who want a locked, guaranteed rate from an A+-rated carrier and do not need an income rider
MYGA8yrA+Review →
Nationwide Summit
Buyers who want a straightforward, no-fee FIA from a top-rated carrier with simple cap-based crediting and no unnecessary complexity
FIA7yr 3.8Review →
Advisory Retirement Income Annuity (NY)
New York investors working with a fee-only advisor who want tax-deferred market participation and the option to layer on a lifetime income guarantee without paying a commission or accepting a surrender period
Variable0yr 3.8Yes
Empire Advisory NY III: 1.45% current / 1.60% max (single life); 1.60% current / 1.90% max (joint). Core Advisory / Accelerated Advisory: 1.30% current / 1.50% max (single), 1.60% current / 1.90% max (joint). Pro 4: 0.45% current / 0.55% max (single), 0.60% current / 0.70% max (joint). Fees based on Benefit Base, charged annually. fee
Review →
Secure Growth 3-Year with ROP
Conservative savers who want a short-term locked rate from a top-rated carrier and need the peace of mind that they cannot lose principal under any surrender scenario
MYGA3yrA+Review →
Secure Growth 4-Year with ROP
Conservative savers who want a short locked-rate annuity from a top-rated carrier with a built-in return-of-premium safety net and no market value adjustment risk
MYGA4yrA+Review →
Peak 5 Series B
Buyers who want a shorter FIA commitment, principal protection, and a no-fee contract from a highly rated carrier without paying for income features they don't need
FIA5yr 3.8Review →
Platinum Edge 3-Year
Conservative savers who want a short, low-minimum guaranteed-rate contract from a highly rated carrier and don't need to touch the money during the surrender period
MYGA3yrA+Review →
Platinum Edge 4-Year
Buyers who want a short locked-rate commitment and prefer a simple guaranteed-rate design with a flexible entry account
MYGA4yrA+Review →
Platinum Edge 5-Year
Conservative savers who want a guaranteed rate for five years and already work with a registered representative
MYGA5yrA+Review →
Platinum Edge 9-Year
Conservative savers who want a locked fixed rate from a top-rated carrier and do not need to access principal during the surrender period
MYGA9yrA+Review →
Platinum Edge 10-Year
Buyers with long-term money who want a guaranteed rate for a decade and value a carrier-backed SEC-registered platform with mild surrender charges
MYGA10yrA+Review →
Destination B 2.0 (NY)
New York residents who want tax-deferred market participation across a broad subaccount lineup and may add a lifetime income rider later
Variable7yr 3.6Review →
Destination Navigator 2.0 L-Share
Investors who want broad market exposure inside a tax-deferred wrapper, value a shorter 4-year surrender window, and may want to bolt on an optional lifetime income rider later
Variable4yr 3.60.50% on cumulative household premiums $500,000–$999,999; 1.00% on $1,000,000+Review →
Destination Architect 2.0
Fee-based advisory clients who want tax-deferred market growth across a deep subaccount menu, full liquidity, and the option to bolt on income or death-benefit guarantees later
Variable0yr 3.6Review →
Destination Freedom B-Share
Tax-deferral-focused investors who want broad market participation through sub-accounts, a shorter surrender commitment than most variable annuities, and optional death-benefit protection without paying for a lifetime-income rider
Variable5yr 3.5Review →
Destination All American Gold 2.0
Buyers who want tax-deferred market participation through a deep subaccount lineup and may bolt on a lifetime income rider later
Variable7yr 3.50.50% on cumulative household premiums $500,000-$999,999; 1.00% on cumulative household premiums $1,000,000+Review →
Destination All American Gold 2.0 L-Share
Buyers who want true market participation through a broad subaccount lineup, a short 4-year surrender window, and the option to add lifetime income or an enhanced death benefit only if they want it
Variable4yr 3.5Review →
Destination Navigator 2.0 B-Share (NY)
New York residents who want tax-deferred investment growth across a large subaccount menu and are willing to bolt on an optional income or enhanced death-benefit rider
Variable7yr 3.5Review →
JP Morgan Multi-Asset Choice
Fee-based advisory clients who want a low-cost, tax-deferred investment chassis with a deep subaccount menu and no surrender period
Variable0yr 3.4Review →
JP Morgan Multi-Asset Choice (NY)
New York investors already working with a fee-based advisor who want low-cost, tax-deferred access to a deep subaccount lineup without surrender charges
Variable0yr 3.4Review →
Destination B 2.0
Buyers who specifically want broad market participation inside a tax-deferred wrapper and are willing to pay the variable-annuity cost stack to get it
Variable7yr 3.40.50% on $500,000-$999,999; 1.00% on $1,000,000+Review →
Personal Income Annuity (NY)
New York buyers working through a Fidelity advisor who want a low base-cost variable annuity with an optional guaranteed-income rider attached to a single balanced portfolio
Variable5yr 3.4Yes
1.30% annually, charged on benefit base fee
Review →
Destination Freedom C-Share
Tax-deferred investors who want full liquidity from day one and are willing to pay a recurring fee for the privilege of no surrender charges
Variable0yr 3.3Review →
Destination Future
Merrill Lynch clients who want tax-deferred market exposure across a deep subaccount menu and are willing to add an optional income or death-benefit rider for an extra fee
Variable7yr 3.3Review →
Indexed Principal Protection
Plan participants in a 401(k), 401(a), or 457(b) who want a principal-protected, FIA-style option inside their employer retirement plan without committing to any surrender period
FIA0yr 3.3Review →
02

About Nationwide

Nationwide is one of the largest and most diversified insurance and financial services companies in the world. Their annuity division offers a comprehensive range of products including variable, fixed, and indexed annuities. With nearly a century of experience, Nationwide combines financial strength with product innovation.

03

How we scored them

Income Options88/100
Financial Strength95/100
Fees & Costs82/100
Flexibility90/100
Customer Service88/100
04

The tradeoffs

What works
  • Superior financial strength ratings
  • Wide range of annuity types (variable, fixed, indexed)
  • Strong brand recognition and trust
  • Robust online tools and account management
  • Nationwide network of financial advisors
What to watch
  • Variable annuity fees can be higher than average
  • Some products have complex structures
  • Fixed rates not always the most competitive
  • Minimum investments can be higher
05

What you could receive

Estimated guaranteed lifetime income based on a single premium payment. Actual rates may vary.

InvestmentAgeMonthlyAnnualGuarantee
$100,00060$525$6,300Lifetime
$250,00065$1,460$17,520Lifetime
$500,00065$2,920$35,040Lifetime
$1,000,00070$6,600$79,200Lifetime
06

Fee schedule

Fee typeAmountDescription
Annual Contract Fee$0 - $50Varies by product
Income Rider Fee1.00% - 1.25%Annual fee for income rider
Surrender ChargeVariesDeclining surrender charge schedule
07

Early withdrawal penalties

Charges apply to amounts above the annual free withdrawal (typically 10%).

Yr 1Yr 2Yr 3Yr 4Yr 5Yr 6Yr 7Yr 8Yr 9Yr 10
9%8%7%6%5%4%3%2%1%0%
08

Best fit for these buyers

Investors wanting a well-known, trusted brand
Those seeking variable annuity options
Retirees who value advisor access
Ages 50-70 with diversified retirement needs
09

Frequently asked questions

Is Nationwide a good annuity company?
Nationwide earns an average rating of 3.9/5 across the 55 products we've reviewed, with an AM Best rating of A+ and S&P rating of A+. Their financial strength is rated "Superior" with $280+ Billion in total assets. Nationwide is particularly strong in financial strength.
How much income can I get from a Nationwide annuity?
Income depends on your investment amount and age. For example, a $500,000 investment at age 65 could generate approximately $35,040 per year in guaranteed lifetime income. A $250,000 investment at the same age could generate about $17,520 per year.
What are the fees for Nationwide annuities?
Nationwide charges Annual Contract Fee: $0 - $50, Income Rider Fee: 1.00% - 1.25%, Surrender Charge: Varies. Fee structures vary by product — review the specific product details before purchasing.
What is the surrender period for Nationwide annuities?
Nationwide annuities typically have a 10-year surrender period. Charges start at 9% in year one and decline to 0% in the final year. Most products allow 10% annual free withdrawals without penalty.

See your Nationwide income projection

  • Personalized estimate
  • Based on age, premium & goals
  • No pressure, no pitch.
Compare Nationwide