Regulation · State guide
New York annuity rules
Top 5-year MYGA
6.30%
B++ or better, yield to surrender
- FIA S&P cap
- 17.00%
- As of
- Oct 27
What New York law says
Free-look period
If the annuity you bought replaced an existing policy or contract, New York gives you at least 60 days from delivery to return it and get a full refund of your premium.
11 NYCRR § 51.6(d) (Insurance Regulation 60), New York Dept. of Financial Services — Third Amendment to 11 NYCRR 51, Insurance Regulation 60, § 51.6(d) right to return a replacement policy or contractVerified 2026-08-25
What your agent owes you
When recommending that you buy or replace an annuity, the producer (or the insurer, if no producer is involved) must act in your best interest, considering only your interests and not the producer's compensation.
11 NYCRR § 224.4 (Insurance Regulation 187), New York Dept. of Financial Services — First Amendment to 11 NYCRR 224, Insurance Regulation 187, § 224.4 duties of insurers and producers on sales transactionsVerified 2026-08-25
How New York taxes annuity income
If you were 59½ or older for the full tax year, New York lets you exclude up to $20,000 of qualified pension and annuity income each year from your New York taxable income; any annuity income above that is taxed as ordinary New York income.
N.Y.S. Dep't of Taxation and Finance — pension and annuity income exclusion, $20,000, New York State Department of Taxation and Finance — information for seniorsVerified 2026-08-25
Who regulates annuities in New York
Fixed annuities are insurance products, so they are overseen by the state insurance department rather than by the SEC. The department licenses the carriers and the producers who sell them, and it takes consumer complaints.
The New York guaranty association
Every state has a life and health insurance guaranty association that steps in when a member insurer fails. Coverage terms are set by state law and differ by state and by product. Contact the association directly for what applies to a specific contract.
Life & Health Insurance Company Guaranty Corporation of New York
Compare annuity rates in New York
Get a personalized annuity review or see current rates filed in New York.
This page is educational and is not legal, tax, or insurance advice. State rules change. Verify anything here with the New York insurance department before acting.
Compare annuity rates in New York
Answer a few questions and compare the products that fit you, on today's rates.