Annuity Atlas
Reviews

Product review · Guaranty Income Life · Not approved in AK, HI, ME, NY

Rate Lock Fee-Based 8-Year review

Rate Lock Fee-Based 8-Year is Guaranty Income Life's MYGA for the RIA and fee-only advisor channel. It offers a fixed rate locked for the full 8-year term, no commission load in the crediting structure, and a minimal-feature design that keeps things clean. It is not a fit for clients who need liquidity, want index-linked upside, or are outside the fee-based advisory relationship this product is built around.

Our rating

4.1★ / 5
Good Option
Fee-only and RIA clients who want a clean 8-year locked rate with no commission load baked into the crediting
Get my free quote
Surrender
8 years
Issue ages
0-90
MGSV
87.5% of premiums at 1-3%
Free withdrawal
5% of prior anniversary accumulation value, starting in year 2 ($250 minimum); RMD available anytime
01

Why it earned this rating

Our assessment

The Rate Lock Fee-Based 8-Year earns a good rating primarily because it is the right tool for a specific distribution context: fee-only advisory accounts where the advisor's compensation comes from an AUM fee rather than a commission embedded in the product. The absence of a surrender commission load means the crediting rate is not artificially compressed to pay distribution costs, which is a genuine structural advantage in the fee-based channel. What holds it back from a higher rating is the 8-year commitment — longer than the median MYGA for this use case — combined with an MVA that can make early exits more expensive than the stated surrender charges suggest.

02

The short version

This is an 8-year guaranteed-rate annuity designed specifically for fee-only advisory accounts. The practical difference from the standard commission version is straightforward: because no upfront commission is loaded into the product, the available crediting rate is not suppressed to recover distribution costs. For clients in a fee-based relationship, that structural efficiency matters. The tradeoff is the same as any MYGA — you are exchanging 8 years of full liquidity for a locked rate and the safety of Guaranty Income Life's balance sheet. The MVA is worth understanding before purchase.

03

Key facts

Surrender Period
8 years
Issue Ages
0-90
Minimum Premium
$10,000
Free Withdrawal
5% of prior anniversary accumulation value, starting in year 2 ($250 minimum); RMD available anytime
Income Rider
Not available
Premium Bonus
None
04

The full review

Is Guaranty Income Life Rate Lock Fee-Based 8-Year a Good Annuity?

Yes, for clients in a fee-only or RIA advisory relationship who have genuine 8-year money and want principal protection with a locked yield. For that specific buyer, the fee-based share class offers a clean rate without the compression that comes from embedding an upfront commission into the product pricing. It is a less compelling choice if the client's advisor works on a commission basis — in that case, the standard commission version of the same product typically applies.

Why Someone Would Buy This Annuity

The main reason a fee-only or RIA client buys this is to get a predictable, multi-year guaranteed rate without the commission load embedded in the crediting. In a fee-based relationship, the advisor charges separately for advice, so there is no structural need to pay a distributor through the insurance product itself. That can translate into a more favorable rate than a comparable commission product. The secondary reason is simplicity: this is a fixed-rate, principal-protected instrument with no index complexity, no rider fees, and no moving parts beyond the rate itself.

Who This Annuity Is Best For

I think this product is best for clients who are already working with a fee-only financial advisor or RIA, have money they are confident they will not need for eight years, and want the safety of a guaranteed rate with principal protection. It is appropriate across qualified and non-qualified accounts given the broad 0-90 issue age range. It is less appropriate for clients who may need liquidity during the surrender period, whose advisor operates on a commission basis, who want index-linked upside potential, or who are primarily focused on generating lifetime income.

What You're Really Buying Here

A MYGA — Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity — is functionally an insurance contract that behaves like a certificate of deposit but with tax deferral and, in the fee-based version, no commission cost built into the yield. You deposit a lump sum, Guaranty Income Life credits interest at a fixed rate for the full 8-year term, and the money compounds tax-deferred until you withdraw it. The carrier takes on interest-rate risk in exchange for having use of your capital. The "fee-based" designation means this share class was structured for advisors who charge separately for their services — the company does not need to pay them through the product, so the pricing structure can reflect that. What you are not buying is any kind of market participation, index-linked upside, or income guarantee.

How the Core Feature Works

The Rate Lock Fee-Based credits interest at a fixed rate for the entire 8-year term. The rate is tiered by premium band: a low band covering deposits of $10,000 to $99,999, a medium band from $100,000 to $249,999, and a high band starting at $250,000. As of the brochure date, the low band carried a 4.35% rate and both higher bands were at 4.45%. These rates are guaranteed for the full term — there is no annual reset, no crediting election to manage, and no index to track. Interest compounds inside the contract tax-deferred until withdrawal. The simplicity is the feature: once you lock in, the math is fixed for 8 years.

Why the Secondary Feature Matters

The most meaningful secondary feature is the fee-based share class structure itself. In a commission-based annuity, the carrier prices the product to recover upfront distributor compensation — that cost is typically embedded in a lower credited rate, a longer surrender schedule, or both. In a fee-based version, that compensation pathway does not exist because the advisor is paid separately. The result is a crediting rate that reflects only the economics of the insurance contract rather than the economics of the distribution chain. For clients in a fee-only advisory relationship, this is not a trivial difference over an 8-year compounding period. The terminal illness and nursing home confinement waivers are also worth noting — they provide a defined exit path if the client's health situation changes materially before the surrender period ends.

Liquidity and Surrender Schedule

You are trading 8 years of full liquidity for a locked rate. The free-withdrawal provision allows 5% of the prior anniversary accumulation value starting in year 2, with a $250 minimum per withdrawal. Required minimum distributions can be taken at any time without surrender charges, which makes this product compatible with qualified accounts subject to RMDs. Systematic withdrawal schedules are available monthly, quarterly, semi-annually, or annually for planning convenience.

Withdrawals in excess of the free amount are subject to surrender charges that decline from 9% in year 1 to 2% in year 8, plus a Market Value Adjustment — MVA. The MVA is an interest-rate-based adjustment that can add to or reduce your effective exit cost depending on where rates are at the time of the withdrawal. If rates have risen since you bought the contract, the MVA works against you; if rates have fallen, it can work in your favor. The key point is that the stated surrender charge is not the whole story — the MVA can materially increase the effective cost of an early exit in a rising-rate environment. Plan to hold the full 8 years unless the nursing home or terminal illness waiver applies.

Contract YearSurrender Charge
19%
28%
37%
46%
55%
64%
73%
82%
Fees and Tradeoffs

There are no explicit contract fees or rider fees on this product. That is straightforward — it is a fixed-rate MYGA with no optional riders available. The advisor's compensation is not embedded here; it is paid outside the product through the advisory fee agreement.

The real cost of this annuity is opportunity cost: you are locking in a rate for 8 years. If rates rise significantly after purchase, you do not benefit, and early exit is expensive due to the combined effect of surrender charges and the MVA. If rates fall, the locked rate looks better in retrospect. The MGSV — Minimum Guaranteed Surrender Value — of 87.5% of premiums growing at 1-3% provides a floor on what you can receive even in a worst-case surrender scenario, which offers some protection against extreme outcomes. The product is not available in Alaska, Hawaii, Maine, or New York.

Product snapshot
FeatureDetails
Product TypeFixed Annuity
Surrender Period8 years
Issue Ages0-90
Minimum Premium$10,000
Crediting MethodsFixed Rate
Free Withdrawal5% of prior anniversary accumulation value, starting in year 2 ($250 minimum); RMD available anytime
MGSV87.5% of premiums at 1-3%
Death BenefitFull Accumulation Value Before Annuitization
Income RiderNot available
Premium BonusNone
AvailabilityNot approved in AK, HI, ME, NY
Carrier snapshot

Legal Entity: Guaranty Income Life Insurance Company

Parent: Kuvare US Holdings, Inc.

A.M. Best Rating: A-

Guaranty Income Life is part of Kuvare US Holdings, a holding company focused on insurance and reinsurance. The A- A.M. Best rating reflects adequate financial strength for a mid-market carrier. It is not a household name in the annuity space, which means advisors should do their own due diligence on carrier stability before placing significant assets here. The rating is solid but not exceptional.

Final take

Rate Lock Fee-Based 8-Year is a clean, low-complexity MYGA that makes most sense in one specific situation: a fee-only or RIA advisory relationship where the client has 8-year money and wants a guaranteed rate without commission-load compression. In that context, the fee-based share class structure is a genuine advantage, and the product delivers on its promise — a fixed rate, principal protection, and tax deferral for the full term.

The reasons to look elsewhere are equally clear. If the client cannot commit 8 years, a shorter MYGA duration is the right answer. If the advisor is commission-based, the standard version of this product applies and the fee-based framing is irrelevant. If the client wants index-linked upside or lifetime income guarantees, a different product type entirely is needed. For clients who fit the profile, this is a functional and appropriately structured option.

Ready to see how it stacks up?

  • Income, fees & ratings compared
  • Across every reviewed product
  • 100% free. No pressure.
Compare annuities