Annuity Atlas
Reviews

Product review · Prudential · Approved in NY only (not approved in all other states per state approvals list)

MyRock Advisor (NY) review

MyRock Advisor (NY) is Prudential's fee-based, no-commission variable annuity for New York. Its strength is structure: no surrender charges, full liquidity, a low 0.40% base contract fee (lower still above $1 million), and roughly 89 subaccounts to build a portfolio from. Its limitation is that it carries pure market risk with no living benefit and no guaranteed income, which is exactly the feature set most people buy a variable annuity to get.

Our rating

3.5★ / 5
Mixed but Competitive
Investors working with a fee-only advisor who want tax-deferred market participation with no surrender charges and a low base contract cost
Get my free quote
Surrender
0 years
Issue ages
0-85
MGSV
N/A
Free withdrawal
N/A
01

Why it earned this rating

Our assessment

MyRock Advisor (NY) is a clean, low-cost advisory variable annuity built for the fee-based world, and on those terms it is competitive: no surrender period, a 0.40% base charge that drops further on large premiums, and a deep subaccount menu. What holds it in the middle of the pack is that, like every accumulation-only VA, it asks you to take full market risk without the living-benefit guarantees that justify the variable-annuity wrapper for most retirement buyers.

02

The short version

This is a tax-deferred investment account dressed as an annuity, sold only through fee-based (RIA) advisors and approved only in New York. You pour money into one of dozens of professionally managed subaccounts, your balance rises and falls with the markets, and there is no surrender period locking you in. There is no income rider and no principal protection, so the entire case for owning it comes down to tax-deferred growth and the absence of surrender charges. If you already have a fee-only advisor managing your money and you have maxed out other tax-advantaged accounts, this is a reasonable place to keep additional non-qualified dollars. If you want guarantees, this is the wrong product.

03

The full review

Is Prudential MyRock Advisor (NY) a Good Annuity?

It depends on why you are shopping. As a low-cost, liquid, tax-deferred investment wrapper inside a fee-based advisory relationship, it is a good fit. As a retirement-income or principal-protection tool, it is not — those features simply are not part of this contract. The value here is the tax deferral and the clean cost structure, not any insurance guarantee.

Why Someone Would Buy This Annuity

The rational reason to buy MyRock Advisor (NY) is tax-deferred growth on money you have already exhausted other shelters for — after maxing a 401(k) and IRA, for example. Because it is an advisory (fee-based) product with no surrender period, your advisor can move money in and out without triggering charges, which makes it behave more like a brokerage account with a tax-deferral overlay. The low base cost is what makes that overlay worth paying for. You would choose this over a taxable account when deferral matters and over a guaranteed annuity when you specifically do not want to pay for guarantees you will not use.

Who This Annuity Is Best For

I think this is best for an investor — typically 45 to 65, still accumulating, comfortable with market risk — who works with a fee-only advisor and has non-qualified money that has outgrown other tax-advantaged accounts. It suits someone who values liquidity and wants their advisor to manage the underlying portfolio actively. It is a poor fit for anyone who needs guaranteed lifetime income, wants downside protection, or does not have an advisory relationship — and since it is only approved in New York, it is irrelevant to buyers in other states.

What You're Really Buying Here

Strip away the word "annuity" and this is a tax-deferred investment account. Your premium buys units in variable subaccounts — mutual-fund-like portfolios spanning stocks, bonds, and blended strategies — and your account value moves with their performance, up or down, with no floor. Unlike a fixed or indexed annuity, there is no crediting formula, no cap, and no participation rate shaping your return; you simply get the market result of the funds you choose, minus fees. The "annuity" benefits you are paying the insurance company for are the tax deferral on gains and the death benefit, not any guarantee on your principal.

How the Core Feature Works

The core engine is the variable subaccount menu — roughly 89 options according to the brochure materials. You and your advisor allocate premium across these subaccounts, and the account value reflects their daily performance. Net subaccount fees run from about 0.09% to 0.89%, layered on top of the base contract charge, with an additional 0.35% Fund Facilitation Fee applying to 31 specific funds. On top of that sits the base contract charge: 0.40% total (0.25% mortality and expense plus 0.15% administration) for net premiums under $1 million, dropping to 0.25% total (0.10% M&E plus 0.15% administration) once net premiums reach $1 million or more. Because there is no surrender period, you can reallocate or exit at any time without a contract-level charge — you get up to 20 free transfers a year, then $10 per transfer after that.

Why the Secondary Feature Matters

The optional Return of Adjusted Purchase Payments death benefit is the most meaningful add-on. For 0.10% assessed daily against account value, it guarantees your beneficiaries receive the greater of the current account value or total premiums paid (reduced proportionally for withdrawals). In plain terms, it protects your heirs from a down market at the moment of death — if your investments have fallen below what you put in, the death benefit still pays back your premiums. Without it, the death benefit is simply the account value, market losses and all. Whether the 0.10% is worth it depends on how much legacy protection matters to you; for a younger accumulator it is a small cost, for an older buyer it can be genuinely valuable.

Liquidity and Surrender Schedule

There is no surrender schedule. This is an RIA / I-share style contract built with no contingent deferred sales charge, so you can withdraw your account value at any time without a contract-level penalty. That is the headline liquidity advantage over a commission-based variable annuity. Standard caveats still apply: withdrawals are subject to ordinary income tax on gains and, before age 59½, a potential 10% IRS penalty, and any withdrawal is taken at the then-current market value, so selling after a downturn locks in losses. Required minimum distributions are accommodated. The practical point is that liquidity is not the constraint here — market risk is.

Fees and Tradeoffs

The fee stack is the whole story. The base contract charge is low for a variable annuity — 0.40% under $1 million and 0.25% above it — and there is no surrender charge to recover commissions, which is the defining feature of the fee-based design. On top of that you pay the net subaccount fees (about 0.09% to 0.89%), the 0.35% Fund Facilitation Fee on 31 of the funds, the optional 0.10% death-benefit charge if you elect it, and a $50 annual contract fee that is waived once account value reaches $100,000. Stacked together, an all-in cost in the 0.6%–1.3% range is realistic depending on fund selection — reasonable for an advisory VA, but a real drag compounding against market returns over time. The trade is straightforward: you accept those layered fees and full market risk in exchange for tax deferral and complete liquidity.

Product snapshot
FeatureDetails
Product TypeVariable Annuity
Surrender PeriodNone
Issue Ages0-85
Minimum Premium$10,000
Crediting MethodsVariable Subaccounts
Free WithdrawalN/A
MGSVN/A
Death BenefitFull Account Value (base); optional Return of Adjusted Purchase Payments Death Benefit equals greater of full account value or premiums paid less proportional withdrawals
Income RiderNot available
Premium BonusNone
AvailabilityApproved in NY only (not approved in all other states per state approvals list)
Carrier snapshot

Legal Entity: Pruco Life Insurance Company of New Jersey

Parent: Prudential Insurance Company of America

A.M Best Rating: A+

Final take

MyRock Advisor (NY) makes sense for one specific buyer: someone working with a fee-only advisor, in New York, who wants a low-cost, fully liquid, tax-deferred home for non-qualified investment dollars and does not want — or want to pay for — guarantees. On those terms it does its job cleanly, and the absence of surrender charges plus the sub-0.50% base cost make it competitive among advisory variable annuities. But it is not a retirement-income product and it offers no protection against losing money in the market. If you are looking for guaranteed lifetime income or principal protection, this is the wrong tool, and you should look at an indexed or income-focused annuity instead. If tax deferral inside a managed, liquid account is genuinely what you need, this is a solid choice within its narrow lane.

Ready to see how it stacks up?

  • Income, fees & ratings compared
  • Across every reviewed product
  • 100% free. No pressure.
Compare annuities