Why it earned this rating
Our assessment
IncomeVantage Pro earns a good rating because it bundles a lifetime income rider into the base contract with no separate rider charge, pairs it with a broad crediting menu and a strong A+ carrier, and adds an enhanced death benefit. What holds it back from a top-tier score is the income engine itself: the 2.00% compound roll-up is on the lower end for an income-focused FIA, and the 10-year surrender schedule is long and front-loaded. It is a solid fit for income-focused deferral, but it is not the most aggressive income builder in its peer group.
The short version
This is Midland National's 10-year income-focused fixed indexed annuity, built around a lifetime income rider that comes baked into the contract rather than added on for an extra fee. The appeal is straightforward: principal protection, a built-in path to lifetime income, and no separate annual rider charge eating into your account value. The catch is that the benefit base grows at a modest 2.00% compounded, the surrender period runs a full ten years, and some of the more attractive-looking crediting strategies carry their own fees. For someone using long-term money to set up future income, it deserves a look. For someone chasing the strongest possible deferred income payout, there are more aggressive roll-ups out there.
Key facts
The full review
Is Midland National IncomeVantage Pro a Good Annuity?
Yes, for the right buyer. This is a good annuity for someone who wants protected lifetime income, likes the idea of a built-in rider that does not charge a separate annual fee, and is comfortable planning several years ahead before turning income on. It is less appealing for someone who wants short-term liquidity, the strongest possible income roll-up, or a shorter surrender commitment.
Why Someone Would Buy This Annuity
The main reason to buy IncomeVantage Pro is to set up future protected lifetime income while keeping principal safe from market losses along the way. The built-in Withdrawal Benefit Rider XI means you are not layering on a separate fee-charging income rider the way many income FIAs require. For a buyer who plans to defer and then turn on guaranteed lifetime withdrawals, the absence of an explicit rider fee is a real practical advantage, because that fee is one of the things that quietly drags on contract value in competing products.
Who This Annuity Is Best For
I think this annuity is best for someone in the pre-retirement or early-retirement window, roughly in their late 50s through their 70s, who wants to convert long-term money into a future income stream and is willing to leave it untouched for several years. It fits both qualified money like an IRA and non-qualified savings, and the built-in rider makes it simplest for people who do not want to evaluate optional rider add-ons. It is less attractive for someone who wants growth above all else, expects to need frequent access to principal beyond the 5% free amount, or wants a shorter lockup than ten years.
What You're Really Buying Here
You are not really buying stock market upside here. You are buying a lifetime income framework wrapped around a principal-protected annuity. The heart of the contract is the built-in Withdrawal Benefit Rider XI. Your premium establishes a benefit base, that base grows at 2.00% compounded during the deferral period, and when you eventually activate income, your age and the contract's withdrawal factors determine how much you can take for life. The index-crediting menu sits underneath all of that, but make no mistake: this product is designed to support income guarantees first and accumulation second.
How the Core Feature Works
The core feature is the built-in Withdrawal Benefit Rider XI. Unlike most income FIAs, there is no separate rider fee disclosed in the materials, which is unusual and worth confirming with a current rate sheet, since some carriers fund a no-fee rider by offering lower crediting rates instead. During deferral, the benefit base grows at a 2.00% compound annual roll-up. That 2.00% figure is medium-confidence in the source materials, so verify it directly before relying on it. When you turn income on, you take guaranteed lifetime withdrawals based on the benefit base rather than the account value, which is what protects your income even if market-linked crediting is flat. In plain English, the rider gives you a predictable future income number to plan around, and the 2.00% roll-up is what nudges that number higher the longer you wait.
Why the Secondary Feature Matters
The most meaningful secondary feature is the crediting menu paired with the enhanced death benefit. The contract offers a deep set of strategies, including annual and two-year point-to-point options using caps, participation rates, index margins, and enhanced participation rates, plus a monthly point-to-point cap option and an inverse performance trigger, across six different indices ranging from the S&P 500 to volatility-controlled and ESG benchmarks. That breadth lets you position the accumulation side based on how you think different markets may behave. On top of that, the enhanced death benefit pays the greater of 125% of surrender value or 250% of premium less withdrawals to beneficiaries, which adds a legacy dimension. That death benefit description is low-confidence in the source materials, so treat the specific percentages as something to verify.
Liquidity and Surrender Schedule
This annuity is built for long-term retirement dollars, not short-term cash. Starting in year two, you can withdraw up to 5% of your beginning-of-year accumulation value each year without penalty. Anything above that during the surrender period is hit with both a surrender charge and a market value adjustment, or MVA, which means your penalty can move up or down depending on where interest rates have gone since you bought the contract. The schedule is long and front-loaded: it holds at 10% for the first five contract years before stepping down, and it does not reach zero until year eleven. There is also a useful detail in the fine print called the AV true-up, a one-time refund of the difference if your total interest credited ends up less than your total strategy charges, provided you have not taken excess penalty-free withdrawals. Even with that protection, this is not a contract to treat like emergency money.
Fees and Tradeoffs
The headline here is what you do not pay: there is no separate income rider fee and no disclosed base contract fee in the available materials. The real cost shows up in two places. First, the enhanced participation rate crediting options carry a strategy fee, charged as an annual percentage and multiplied by the number of years in the crediting term, deducted at term end or at withdrawal. So the more aggressive-looking participation strategies are not free. Second, and more important, the tradeoff is structural rather than a line-item charge. A no-fee built-in income rider with a modest 2.00% roll-up tells you the income guarantees are funded by keeping crediting terms conservative. You are trading explicit fees for a slower-growing benefit base and likely tighter caps and participation rates than an accumulation-first product would offer.
Product snapshot
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Product Type | Income-Focused Fixed Indexed Annuity |
| Surrender Period | 10 years |
| Issue Ages | 40-79 |
| Minimum Premium | $20,000 |
| Indices | S&P 500, S&P 500 Dynamic Intraday TCA Index, S&P 500 Multi-Asset Risk Control 5% Excess Return Index, Fidelity Multifactor Yield Index 5% ER, Nasdaq-100 Volatility Control 12% Index, BlackRock ESG US 5% Index ER |
| Crediting Methods | Fixed, Annual Point-to-Point with Participation Rate, Annual Point-to-Point with Cap Rate, Annual Point-to-Point with Index Margin, Annual Point-to-Point with Enhanced Participation Rate, Two-year Point-to-Point with Index Margin, Two-year Point-to-Point with Participation Rate, Two-year Point-to-Point with Enhanced Participation Rate, Monthly Point-to-Point with Cap Rate, Annual Inverse Performance Trigger |
| Free Withdrawal | 5% of beginning of year accumulation value annually, penalty-free beginning year 2 |
| MGSV | 87.5% of premiums at 1-3% |
| Death Benefit | Account value plus appreciation-to-date OR Benefit Base if annuitized for minimum five-year period |
| Income Rider | Built-in |
| Premium Bonus | None |
| Availability | Variations approved in CA, MA, SD. Not approved in NY. Available plan types: 403(b), IRA, NQ, Roth IRA, SEP IRA (except 403(b) not available with this product) |
Carrier snapshot
Legal Entity: Midland National Life Insurance Company
Parent: Sammons Financial Group
A.M. Best Rating: A+
Midland National is a large, established carrier owned by Sammons Financial Group, and its A+ rating from A.M. Best places it firmly in the upper tier of annuity issuers. For an income product where the whole point is a guarantee you may not collect on for a decade or more, the strength behind the guarantee matters, and this carrier brings real financial backing to it.
Final take
IncomeVantage Pro is a strong fit for the buyer who is genuinely solving a future income problem, wants a built-in rider without a separate annual fee, and can live with a ten-year commitment. The no-fee income rider and the A+ carrier are the two best reasons to notice it, and the broad crediting menu gives you flexibility on the accumulation side.
The caution is just as clear. The 2.00% compound roll-up is modest for an income-focused FIA, so if maximizing your future income number is the goal, you should compare it head-to-head against products with richer roll-ups before deciding. The surrender schedule is long and stays at 10% for five full years. For income-focused buyers who value simplicity and carrier strength over the most aggressive income growth, this is a good option. For buyers chasing the highest deferred payout, it will usually feel a step behind.
