Annuity Atlas
Reviews

Product review · Forethought · Not available in NY

ForeAccumulation II Advisory review

ForeAccumulation II Advisory is Forethought's no-surrender-charge accumulation FIA for fee-based advisors. The structure removes the biggest friction point for advisory clients who expect portfolio flexibility. The index menu spans six indices with cap, participation rate, spread, and performance-triggered crediting methods. What it is not: an income product, a bonus product, or a contract with a built-in rider. It is a clean accumulation vehicle with a protection floor and an MVA to understand.

Our rating

4.1★ / 5
Good Option
Fee-based advisory clients who want principal-protected index-linked growth without a surrender commitment tying up their money
Get my free quote
Surrender
0 years
Issue ages
0-85
MGSV
87.5% of premiums at 1-3%
Free withdrawal
10% of beginning-of-year contract value annually (Year 1); 10% of account value annually (Years 2+); no withdrawal charge waivers during charge period except nursing home and terminal illness
01

Why it earned this rating

Our assessment

ForeAccumulation II Advisory removes the feature that makes most people nervous about FIAs — the surrender charge — and pairs that with a genuinely wide index and crediting menu. For an advisor-channel product, that is the right design. It earns a Good Option rating because the no-surrender structure and index breadth are real, but the actual current crediting rates were not available in the source materials, which prevents a top-tier rating without knowing how the economics look in practice.

02

The short version

This is an advisory-channel fixed indexed annuity built for accumulation with no surrender charges. The main appeal is simple: you get principal protection and a range of index crediting options without locking the client's money into a multi-year surrender schedule. The only real exit friction is a market value adjustment that can apply on withdrawals, which is worth understanding before purchasing. There is no income rider and no premium bonus — this is a growth-oriented contract for clients who want index-linked upside potential with downside protection.

03

Key facts

Surrender Period
None
Issue Ages
0-85
Minimum Premium
$25,000
Free Withdrawal
10% of beginning-of-year contract value annually (Year 1); 10% of account value annually (Years 2+); no withdrawal charge waivers during charge period except nursing home and terminal illness
Income Rider
Not available
Premium Bonus
None
04

The full review

Is Forethought ForeAccumulation II Advisory a Good Annuity?

For the right client in the right context, yes. This is a genuinely sensible design for an advisor-managed account: no surrender charges means the advisor can adjust the client's allocation without the kind of multi-year penalty that would otherwise make a FIA awkward to hold in a managed portfolio. The tradeoff is that you are still accepting the limits of FIA crediting — caps, spreads, and participation rates shape what you can earn — and you need to verify current rates with the carrier before placing money, since those figures were not fully confirmed in the source materials.

Why Someone Would Buy This Annuity

The rational case here is the combination of principal protection and no surrender charges in an advisory fee structure. A client who wants some insulation from equity drawdowns — but whose advisor also wants the flexibility to manage the portfolio without being locked into a surrender schedule — fits naturally. The six-index menu and four crediting method types give the advisor room to position the contract differently depending on the client's view of markets. The bailout provision also adds a practical safety valve: if any renewal crediting rate falls below the stated bailout rate, the client can exit without penalty.

Who This Annuity Is Best For

I think this contract is best for clients in their 50s or 60s who are working with a fee-based advisor, have a five-to-ten year accumulation horizon, and want a portion of their money in a principal-protected vehicle without accepting a surrender commitment. Both qualified and non-qualified money can work here. It is not a fit for someone shopping for lifetime income guarantees, looking for a premium bonus to boost early account value, or expecting to access more than 10% of their account value in any given year without potential MVA impact.

What You're Really Buying Here

You are buying a principal-protected annuity contract that uses a set of index-based formulas to determine how much interest gets credited each term. None of the crediting methods deliver direct market returns. Caps limit how much upside from a positive index move gets credited. Spreads reduce the calculated index gain before crediting. Participation rates credit a stated percentage of the index move rather than the full amount. Performance-triggered strategies credit a preset amount whenever the index is flat or positive, and nothing when it is negative. The result is a contract where principal is not at risk from index declines, but upside is structurally bounded. For an advisory-channel product, the elimination of surrender charges means the contract behaves more like a long-term savings instrument than a locked-up commitment.

How the Core Feature Works

ForeAccumulation II Advisory offers four crediting method types across six indices. Fixed crediting gives a guaranteed rate for the term (the current fixed rate was listed at 3.90% in the source materials, though this can change). Annual point-to-point strategies measure index performance over one year and apply a cap or spread to determine credited interest. Biennial term-end point strategies use a two-year measurement period, which can allow for higher caps than the comparable one-year versions. Performance-triggered strategies credit a preset amount when the index is flat or positive, regardless of how much the index gained.

The six indices — S&P 500, BlackRock Diversa Volatility Control, MSCI EAFE, Franklin US, JP Morgan Cross-Asset Strategy, and PIMCO Balanced — give the advisor meaningful range. Some of the strategy indices include embedded volatility controls and diversification mechanisms that affect how caps and participation rates are set. I'd encourage advisors to look carefully at what each specialty index actually does before allocating client money there, since the construction of those indices is less transparent than a plain S&P 500 strategy.

The participation rate range (100%-230%) and cap range (1%-18%) noted in the source materials are broad ranges across all available strategies, not figures for a single strategy. Actual current rates for each specific crediting option need to be verified with the carrier.

Why the Secondary Feature Matters

The optional Enhanced Death Benefit III rider is the most meaningful secondary feature on this contract. For an accumulation-focused FIA with no income rider, the death benefit option can matter for clients who also have a legacy objective. The rider provides a benefit base equal to premiums paid plus a 10% simple interest roll-up, accumulating for up to 15 years or until the contract anniversary after age 90, whichever comes first. That roll-up is credited to the death benefit base regardless of account performance. The rider costs 0.75% annually for clients aged 0-70 and 1.20% annually for clients aged 71-80.

That fee is a real consideration. For a client whose primary goal is accumulation, adding 0.75%-1.20% in annual drag may not make sense unless there is a genuine legacy motivation. But for clients with a dual objective — grow the account and provide a floor for heirs — the guaranteed roll-up structure makes the rider worth evaluating.

Liquidity and Surrender Schedule

This is one of the cleaner liquidity stories in the FIA category, because there is no surrender charge schedule. Clients can access their account without a multi-year penalty — that is the defining feature of the advisory channel version. The 10% annual free withdrawal provision still applies, and amounts beyond that are not subject to a surrender charge, but an MVA — Market Value Adjustment — can apply. An MVA means the payout on a withdrawal may fluctuate based on interest rate conditions at the time of the withdrawal, which can work in the client's favor or against it depending on the rate environment.

The bailout provision is a meaningful detail: if any renewal crediting strategy rate falls below the contractually stated bailout rate, the client can surrender the contract without any penalty or MVA. That is a real protection against rate deterioration over time. The contract is also RMD-friendly, which matters for qualified money — required minimum distributions can be taken without triggering penalties or MVA. Nursing Care and Terminal Illness waivers are also available.

Fees and Tradeoffs

The base contract carries no explicit annual fee, which is consistent with what most advisory-channel FIAs look like — the compensation model is the advisor's AUM fee, not an internal product charge. The only ongoing product-level cost comes from the optional Enhanced Death Benefit rider (0.75%-1.20% depending on age), which is only relevant if that rider is elected.

The structural cost is in the crediting mechanics. Caps, spreads, and participation rates all shape what the contract actually earns, and these are set by the carrier at renewal. The broad ranges disclosed in the source materials (caps of 1%-18%, spreads of 0%-10%, participation rates of 100%-230%) suggest meaningful variation across strategies. Current rates for each specific strategy need to be confirmed with the carrier before purchase, since the available brochure materials did not provide a current rate table.

Product snapshot
FeatureDetails
Product TypeFixed Indexed Annuity
Surrender PeriodNone
Issue Ages0-85
Minimum Premium$25,000
IndicesS&P 500, BlackRock Diversa Volatility Control Index, MSCI EAFE, Franklin US Index, JP Morgan Cross-Asset Strategy Index, PIMCO Balanced Index
Crediting MethodsFixed crediting, Annual point-to-point indexed crediting, Biennial term-end point indexed crediting, Performance triggered indexed crediting
Free Withdrawal10% of beginning-of-year contract value annually (Year 1); 10% of account value annually (Years 2+); no withdrawal charge waivers during charge period except nursing home and terminal illness
MGSV87.5% of premiums at 1-3%
Death BenefitGreater of contract value or Enhanced Death Benefit if elected; enhanced death benefit payable at no additional cost (beyond optional rider fee), comprised of premiums paid plus guaranteed 10% simple interest roll-up for 15 years or until contract anniversary after age 90, whichever is earlier
Income RiderNot available
Premium BonusNone
AvailabilityNot available in NY
Carrier snapshot

Legal Entity: Forethought Life Insurance Company

Parent: Global Atlantic Financial Group

A.M. Best Rating: A

Forethought is a Global Atlantic subsidiary and a mid-size carrier in the FIA space. Global Atlantic is well-capitalized and has been a meaningful player in the annuity market, particularly in the advisory and institutional distribution channels. The A (Excellent) rating from A.M. Best reflects solid financial standing for a carrier of this size.

Final take

ForeAccumulation II Advisory is a well-structured choice for clients who want principal protection and index-linked accumulation potential without the surrender commitment that makes traditional FIAs awkward in actively managed advisory portfolios. The no-surrender-charge design is the real differentiator here, and the six-index, four-crediting-method menu gives advisors real flexibility in how they position the contract.

What keeps this from being a top-tier rating is the opacity on current crediting rates. The source materials show ranges but not current figures for specific strategies, so advisors should request the current rate sheet directly before placing money. The MVA is also worth explaining clearly to clients — no surrender charge does not mean no exit risk if rates have moved.

This is not a fit for income-focused clients, clients who want a premium bonus, or clients who need more than 10% liquidity access per year without any interest rate sensitivity on the exit. For the right client — accumulation-focused, working with a fee-based advisor, wanting protection with flexibility — it is a sensible contract.

Ready to see how it stacks up?

  • Income, fees & ratings compared
  • Across every reviewed product
  • 100% free. No pressure.
Compare annuities